TOCA – On Being & Becoming

Mary of Deleuze.png

Evolving the Internet: From Structures of “Being” to Flows of “Becoming”

The digital realm, since its inception, has been characterized by its ceaseless dynamism. From the early days of ARPANET to the globalized web of today, the internet has seen transformations both profound and incremental. Yet, at its core, the internet was conceived as a static space—structured and compartmentalized—epitomized by the classic website. This static architecture, which we can term as “being,” served as a foundational pillar for the information age. It was where businesses established their digital presence, where communities congregated, and where content found permanence. However, with the evolution of technology and shifts in user behavior, it’s becoming evident that this model, while revolutionary in its time, may be reaching its limits.

As users, our interactions with the digital realm have grown far more fluid and complex. No longer satisfied with mere information retrieval or basic interactions, we seek experiences that are continually evolving—platforms and spaces that echo our own dynamic nature. This emerging paradigm can best be encapsulated by the term “becoming,” an ever-shifting state that acknowledges the transient, evolving nature of user intent and the digital world at large.

This essay seeks to explore the mounting tension between these two paradigms—between the traditional structures of “being” and the emergent flow of “becoming.” In doing so, we’ll delve deep into the challenges faced by the existing internet model, discuss the transformative potential of a new architectural framework, and reimagine the business models and strategies that could define the future of the digital realm.

II. The Traditional Internet: A Realm of “Being”

In the early days of the World Wide Web, websites emerged as the primary conduits of digital interaction. These online portals, with their web pages and hyperlinks, mirrored the structural rigidity of the physical entities they represented, whether it be libraries, offices, or marketplaces. Essentially, the internet became a digital replication of our physical world, inheriting its boundaries and inherent static nature.

From a structural standpoint, websites epitomize the “being” state. They are like digital storefronts or office buildings, designed with a sense of permanence in mind. Businesses rushed to stake their claim in this new digital frontier, building websites as one would construct buildings: with foundational pillars, defined boundaries, and an expectation of long-term existence. Over time, as technologies improved, these digital entities might get a facelift or expansion, but the foundational premise remained the same—provide users with a steady, reliable, and consistent experience.

Businesses operating on the early internet adopted strategies that aimed for vertical dominance. The philosophy was straightforward: establish a stronghold in a specific niche, create barriers to entry, and then continuously optimize and expand. This model was heavily influenced by traditional business tactics, and it’s no wonder that the digital titans of today, from Amazon to Google, initially thrived by establishing monopolies within their respective verticals. The idea was to be the singular, go-to destination for a specific need or service.

Yet, as the digital age progresses, cracks have started to appear in this model. The strains are manifold:

  1. User Expectations: Modern internet users, armed with powerful devices and a plethora of options, demand more than just static interactions. They seek dynamic experiences that evolve with their needs and preferences.
  2. Technological Advancements: The rise of artificial intelligence, augmented reality, blockchain, and other emerging technologies challenges the very foundation of the static website. These technologies call for platforms that can adapt, evolve, and respond in real-time.
  3. Competitive Landscape: In a world where startups can disrupt established players overnight, relying solely on a static model of “being” is risky. The barriers to entry, once formidable, are now more permeable than ever.
  4. Shift in Value Capture: Traditional methods of value capture, such as advertising or straightforward e-commerce, are facing challenges. Users are wary of intrusive ads, and the e-commerce landscape is so saturated that differentiation becomes difficult.

In essence, the traditional “being” model of the internet, while pioneering and transformative in its early days, is grappling with an existential crisis. The static nature of websites, and the business strategies they underpin, are increasingly at odds with the vibrant, dynamic tapestry of the modern digital realm.

III. The Concept of ‘Becoming’ and Its Rising Importance

Amidst the changing contours of the digital realm, a new paradigm has begun to assert its relevance, reflecting the shift in user behaviors, expectations, and the very fabric of internet evolution. This paradigm, aptly termed “becoming,” stands in stark contrast to the traditional, static nature of “being” and resonates more deeply with the modern internet user’s pulse.

At its core, the “becoming” paradigm acknowledges the transient, fluid, and dynamic nature of digital interactions. It posits that the internet isn’t just a repository of information or a static space for interactions, but rather an ever-evolving entity that should be in a constant state of metamorphosis, adapting to and mirroring the needs and intents of its users. Instead of acting as mere consumers of fixed content, users are now co-creators, participants in a shared journey of digital exploration and innovation.

This shift towards “becoming” can be attributed to several factors:

  1. User Needs: The digital-native generation seeks platforms that can evolve with them, offering personalized, adaptive experiences that resonate with their ever-shifting interests and lifestyles.
  2. The Pace of Innovation: The rapid advancements in technology ensure that the digital landscape is in a continuous state of flux. Platforms that cannot adapt quickly become obsolete.
  3. Collaborative Creation: The rise of platforms like GitHub, TikTok, and others emphasize collaborative content creation and interaction, furthering the idea of an evolving digital space.

The traditional model of “being,” with its static websites and fixed structures, struggles to cater to these dynamic intents. While it offers stability, it lacks the malleability and responsiveness that modern users crave. It’s akin to having a grand castle on a coastline; while majestic and sturdy, it’s at the mercy of the ever-changing tides and cannot move or adapt to the shifting sands.

Drawing parallels to real-world analogies, one can think of “being” as building castles—grand, permanent, but ultimately fixed in place. In contrast, “becoming” can be likened to constructing ships—agile, adaptable, and designed for exploration. While castles represent defense, stability, and static dominance, ships symbolize journeying, evolution, and adaptability. In the vast ocean of the internet, it’s becoming clear that the future belongs to those who can navigate its currents, harness its winds, and embark on journeys of continuous discovery rather than those who remain anchored to a singular spot.

This shift from “being” to “becoming” is not just a theoretical concept but a pressing imperative. It underscores the need for businesses, developers, and internet architects to rethink their strategies, to move away from building digital castles and start crafting vessels capable of riding the waves of change.

IV. A Deeper Dive: Object-Oriented Internet & TOCA Framework

The concept of “becoming” underscores a pressing need for a more fluid and adaptable digital infrastructure. While the notion of constant evolution in the digital space is alluring, it poses a pertinent question: how can such a malleable and responsive structure be achieved? Enter the TOCA framework—a groundbreaking architecture that could very well shape the future of the internet.

TOCA, an acronym for Tokens, Objects, Contracts, and Agents, introduces a modular and dynamic approach to digital design and interaction. These aren’t mere buzzwords; each component represents a foundational building block in constructing an internet that truly embraces the paradigm of “becoming.”

  1. Tokens: At their core, tokens are digital representations of value or access rights. They can symbolize ownership, identity, or any other form of entitlement in the digital realm. Tokens facilitate decentralized transactions and offer a way to embed trust and validation mechanisms directly within the digital ecosystem.
  2. Objects: Objects in the TOCA framework represent modular, self-contained units of functionality or data. They can be thought of as the digital equivalent of Lego bricks, capable of interlocking in myriad ways to create complex structures. This modularity ensures adaptability, allowing systems to evolve by rearranging, adding, or removing these objects as needed.
  3. Contracts: Digital contracts, often realized through smart contracts in blockchain systems, enable self-executing, trustless interactions between parties. They automate processes, reduce the need for intermediaries, and bring about a heightened level of efficiency and transparency to digital engagements.
  4. Agents: Agents act as autonomous digital entities, capable of making decisions, learning from interactions, and evolving over time. Harnessing the power of AI and machine learning, agents represent the next frontier in user personalization and adaptive digital experiences.

What’s truly transformative about the TOCA framework is its emphasis on modularity, dynamism, and adaptability. Instead of constructing vast, monolithic digital structures, TOCA promotes an assembly of interconnected, flexible components. Each component, be it a token, object, contract, or agent, can be upgraded, replaced, or reconfigured without disrupting the entire system. This stands in stark contrast to the traditional model of “being,” where an overhaul or major update often necessitates significant downtime or even a complete rebuild.

The potential of TOCA to redefine the digital landscape is vast. For users, it promises a more personalized, responsive, and empowering experience. Businesses can harness its modularity to innovate at an unprecedented pace, adapting to market shifts with agility. Moreover, the very structure of the internet, traditionally dominated by centralized entities, could see a paradigm shift towards a more decentralized, user-centric model.

In essence, the TOCA framework does not merely serve as a toolkit for a new kind of internet; it embodies the ethos of “becoming.” By championing adaptability, continual evolution, and user empowerment, TOCA could very well lay the foundation for an internet that is ever in flux, ever responsive, and ever aligned with the dynamic tapestry of human intent and innovation.

V. A Paradigm Shift for Internet Entrepreneurs: From Monopolies to Episodic Engagements

Historically, the narrative of success in the digital domain has been dominated by tales of monopolistic dominance. Internet giants, from social media behemoths to e-commerce platforms, have scaled dizzying heights by creating and occupying vast, centralized spaces, effectively sidelining competition. However, as we stand at the crossroads of digital evolution, it’s becoming clear that this approach, though undeniably successful in the past, may not be the most sustainable or rewarding path forward.

The traditional model of seeking monopolistic dominance is not without its critiques:

  1. Limitations on Innovation: Monopolies, by nature, can stifle competition. While this provides a secure and uncontested space for the dominant player, it often leads to complacency, slowing the pace of innovation.
  2. User Dependency: A monopolistic approach tends to prioritize platform growth over user needs. The primary aim becomes user retention at all costs, sometimes even at the expense of user satisfaction.
  3. Vulnerability to Disruption: While monopolies might seem invincible, their very size and static nature can make them vulnerable to agile startups that introduce disruptive innovations.

In contrast to this established narrative, a new vision is emerging, painting internet ventures in an entirely different light. This vision sees digital enterprises not as vast, unending empires but as episodic, value-rich engagements. Here, the emphasis is not on creating a permanent digital real estate but on crafting intense, high-value episodes of user interaction, not dissimilar to how entertainment productions operate. Each episode, or venture, delivers a concentrated dose of value, captures user attention, and then gracefully makes way for the next venture.

There’s undeniable merit to this episodic approach:

  1. Adaptability: By focusing on short-to-mid term engagements, businesses can remain agile, quickly adapting to user preferences, technological advancements, and market dynamics.
  2. Intense User Interactions: Shorter, episodic ventures can offer users more immersive and enriching experiences. These ventures can command users’ undivided attention, providing them with unparalleled value.
  3. Innovation Catalyst: The episodic model encourages continuous innovation. With each new venture, there’s an opportunity to experiment, iterate, and refine.

However, the transition to this new model poses its challenges:

  1. Redefining Success Metrics: Success in the episodic model is not measured by sheer user numbers or longevity but by the intensity and value of each interaction.
  2. Resource Management: The episodic model demands a different approach to resource allocation, with a focus on delivering peak value in short bursts.
  3. User Transition: Educating and transitioning users from a mindset of platform loyalty to one of episodic engagement will be crucial.

Yet, these challenges are surmountable, especially when weighed against the potential rewards. The episodic approach promises a digital landscape where innovation thrives, users are constantly delighted, and entrepreneurs can harness the dynamism inherent in the “becoming” paradigm.

In essence, the digital realm’s future might not be dominated by a few monopolistic giants but by a multitude of agile, value-driven ventures, each offering episodic bursts of brilliance, and collectively crafting an ever-evolving tapestry of digital experiences.

VI. Conclusion: Embracing the Wave of ‘Becoming’

The ceaseless march of digital progress has always been punctuated by revolutions in thinking, with each new paradigm shift offering a fresh lens to view and engage with the internet’s sprawling expanse. Our journey through the traditional constructs of ‘being’ and the emerging ethos of ‘becoming’ has underscored an undeniable truth: the digital realm is not static; it’s alive, pulsating, and constantly evolving.

At the heart of our discourse lies the pressing need to transition from structures grounded in permanence to dynamic models that embrace flux. The traditional static ‘being’ structures, while foundational and critical to the early internet’s growth, are beginning to show cracks under the sheer weight of user intent and evolving technological landscapes. The rigidity that once offered stability now threatens stagnation.

Forward-thinking entrepreneurs, investors, and developers stand on the frontier of this transformative shift. Their role is not merely to observe but to pioneer—to envisage new structures, foster innovations, and build bridges to the future. The TOCA framework, the episodic approach to digital ventures, and the larger shift towards ‘becoming’ are all testaments to the boundless possibilities that lie ahead.

But envisioning the future is only half the battle. Real change necessitates action—a collective push to challenge the status quo, rethink established norms, and co-create a digital realm that is in harmony with its intrinsic, evolving nature. This is not a mere suggestion but an imperative. To remain relevant, to continually deliver value, and to harness the digital realm’s true potential, there’s a clarion call to every stakeholder: Reimagine. Reinvent. Reshape.

In embracing the wave of ‘becoming’, we’re not just adapting; we’re aligning with the very essence of the internet. This alignment promises a future where the digital realm isn’t just a tool or platform but a living, breathing entity—a reflection of our collective aspirations, innovations, and evolutions.

As we cast our gaze forward, let’s not be content with mere adaptation. Let’s strive for harmony, for resonance, and for a digital future that is as dynamic, diverse, and delightful as the myriad minds that mold it.